Tag: book review

  • Still Spinning But Never Settled

    Still Spinning But Never Settled

    The 2026 One Book One Chicago season finale yesterday offered an opportunity for Samantha Harvey to discuss her award-winning novel Orbital, which was the OBOC selection for its twenty-fifth anniversary season.

    This novel, which Harvey considers a space pastoral, describes a day in the life of six astronauts and cosmonauts from the United States, Britain, Italy, Japan, and Russia aboard an international space station. This day, which consists of sixteen ninety-minute orbits, has these characters continuing experiments, exercising and eating with colleagues, and ruminating about their lives in space and the ones they’ve left behind while a typhoon forms around the Philippines.

    Harvey, who finished this book in the pandemic, successfully captures a sense of isolation despite consistent reminders of connection with the natural planet, which can be seen through the space station windows. These moments, which are lyrically described, vacillate between these characters’ experiences in space, which as unfamiliar seems unnatural, and their impressions of others’ experiences on the only home humans currently have.

    The actions of these characters, who seem intriguing, offer little insight insights into their responses to conflicts, which often occur in the background and elsewhere. The effect for me highlights the limited plot, and also limits the development of these characters, who seem underdeveloped.

    This limited plot also highlights its status as a philosophical novel, which similarly seems incomplete. This book is clearly concerned about environmental issues, but this concern still seems amorphous and general at its end, which leaves me wondering whether I’ve missed something.

    The issue isn’t a dislike of idea novels — I often recommend dystopian, coming-of-age, and sci-fi stories — but rather the extent to which these debates serve the story, which isn’t the case in this situation.

    This book seems more like science realism (sci-realism), and as such asks potentially compelling questions about living and loving, which are often appealing stories for me. The problem in my opinion is that these questions are never articulated, or asked, and addressed in practice, or the characters’ actions, which restricts its relevance and limits its appeal at least for and to me.

    Others clear consider this book noteworthy and worthwhile — why else would it have won the 2024 Booker Prize and been the 2026 One Book One Chicago selection? — but it does little beyond impressing me as a carefully crafted day in space to settle within, and stay with, me and keep me coming back to it for more.

  • Things That Should Be Said

    Things That Should Be Said

    I was more excited about getting to read Elizabeth Strout’s latest novel The Things We Never Say than I am about having read it.

    I tend to like Strout’s novels more than I expect, so I thought that this one, and especially its fifty-seven-year-old high school history teacher protagonist named Artie, would be even better. Artie, like so many of us, is beset by a loneliness that as its epigraph attests comes from his alienation in the midst of others.

    Artie and his wife of many years Evie are struggling with the emotional aftermath of their son Rob’s car crash that killed his girlfriend. Artie discovers that his initial response, which is suicide, isn’t as appealing after he falls into the water while stepping into his sailboat, and that he actually has a desire to live, which he spends the rest of the novel trying to do.

    Other critics praise have praised this novel for many reasons, including this memorable protagonist and its cast of characters and its spare yet sharp style.

    I also admired it for its political and personal timeliness. Loneliness if social media are any indication besets the best of us, and the Trump administration antics can alienate all of us, and in that offer us some common ground.

    I additionally appreciated the intersection of character and plot, and especially Artie’s connection with his son Rob, whose circumstances push them closer and later pull them apart. One contributing cause is Evie’s secret that is exposed yet never confronted, which sadly seems so familiar.

    I could recognize the potential in other choices, such as a shifting POV that promises an unprovided intimacy. That and others reinforce the loneliness theme, and combine for a rhetorically withheld catharsis that cleverly compelled me to keep reading and unfortunately was ultimately unsatisfying.

    This condition can be seen in Artie, whose experiences that he both can and cannot change illustrate the excruciating effect of loneliness around others. His motivation however is never quite clear.

    Is Artie driven by his relative poor childhood or his current political outrage or even a righteous indignation over political and personal circumstances combined with an unavoidable awareness of his relative privilege? The answer can never be found in the accumulation of too many tragedies, one after another until the end.

    I respect Strout’s effort, and her commitment to and confidence in this project. I just believe that the book would have been better served with at least another draft.

    The loss is all that this book could but doesn’t say, which is even more lamentable in light of its final paragraphs and our current circumstances.

  • Frenemies and Families

    Frenemies and Families

    Among Friends by Hal Ebbott is a flawed yet perhaps fascinating novel ostensibly about college friends Emerson and Amos.

    Emerson, who introduces Amos to his friend Claire, appears when Amos needs someone, which cements their connection. This connection eventually includes Claire, whom Amos marries, and Emerson’s wife Retsy as well as their respective daughters Anna and Sophie.

    The point of view shifts throughout the story, and attempts to establish some sympathy with all of the central characters, but at its center as the title suggests is the connection among the four of them, or at least Emerson, Amos, and Claire. These three are balanced by Retsy, who also counterbalances the pressure added by Claire to the friendship between Amos and Emerson.

    Claire, whose history with Emerson at times makes Amos uneasy, displays competing and confusing loyalties throughout the story. Emerson, who assumes that other discuss and even mock him, has an often hidden cruelty that is more revealed than developed.

    This cruelty becomes clear to Amos at the end, and catalyzes his change, which is the final focus of the plot and seems to make the novel in the end his story. For most of it, Amos exhibits a relatively uninteresting uncertainty and insecurity, which makes his eventual courage either more moving or less plausible.

    This courage comes from nowhere except his empathy for his daughter Anna, and specifically his ability to put her needs ahead of his own. As a result, Amos transforms what until that point had been embarrassing, and has been used against him, which almost redeems his emotional suffering and generates an unexpected strength.

    The problem with such an interpretation is the ending, which is too ambiguous and perhaps too rushed. Amos acts independently at the risk of his marriage, and also agrees to Claire’s proposed remedy, which is a family vacation for the three of them that he believes might salvage their marriage.

    Amos and Claire however consult Retsy and Emerson for a recommendation even as they intend once there to follow Anna’s direction. That could refer to her preferences for excursions, which is plausible, but doesn’t rule out an invitation to Emerson, Retsy, and Sophie to join them.

    This second possibility could portend reconciliation and forgiveness, which seems unrealistic or at the very least an awful possibility. I cannot comment on the proper protocol for such situation — I’m being deliberately vague to avoid revealing too much — and yet am horrified by the prospect of returning to regular interactions among them.

    Such an outcome only seems possible, and given the rest of the plot somewhat implausible. If intentional, the novel asks questions about whether we should judge others by their worst moments and if some actions permanently destroy long relationships, in which case the conclusion needs more care, and craft, if only to convince readers that they’re deliberately agitated.

    This more generous interpretation would suggest that this story starts as a slow burn only to burst however briefly into a flame, which would be reason enough to read it.