Author: Christopher Schroeder

  • Still Spinning But Never Settled

    Still Spinning But Never Settled

    The 2026 One Book One Chicago season finale yesterday offered an opportunity for Samantha Harvey to discuss her award-winning novel Orbital, which was the OBOC selection for its twenty-fifth anniversary season.

    This novel, which Harvey considers a space pastoral, describes a day in the life of six astronauts and cosmonauts from the United States, Britain, Italy, Japan, and Russia aboard an international space station. This day, which consists of sixteen ninety-minute orbits, has these characters continuing experiments, exercising and eating with colleagues, and ruminating about their lives in space and the ones they’ve left behind while a typhoon forms around the Philippines.

    Harvey, who finished this book in the pandemic, successfully captures a sense of isolation despite consistent reminders of connection with the natural planet, which can be seen through the space station windows. These moments, which are lyrically described, vacillate between these characters’ experiences in space, which as unfamiliar seems unnatural, and their impressions of others’ experiences on the only home humans currently have.

    The actions of these characters, who seem intriguing, offer little insight insights into their responses to conflicts, which often occur in the background and elsewhere. The effect for me highlights the limited plot, and also limits the development of these characters, who seem underdeveloped.

    This limited plot also highlights its status as a philosophical novel, which similarly seems incomplete. This book is clearly concerned about environmental issues, but this concern still seems amorphous and general at its end, which leaves me wondering whether I’ve missed something.

    The issue isn’t a dislike of idea novels — I often recommend dystopian, coming-of-age, and sci-fi stories — but rather the extent to which these debates serve the story, which isn’t the case in this situation.

    This book seems more like science realism (sci-realism), and as such asks potentially compelling questions about living and loving, which are often appealing stories for me. The problem in my opinion is that these questions are never articulated, or asked, and addressed in practice, or the characters’ actions, which restricts its relevance and limits its appeal at least for and to me.

    Others clear consider this book noteworthy and worthwhile — why else would it have won the 2024 Booker Prize and been the 2026 One Book One Chicago selection? — but it does little beyond impressing me as a carefully crafted day in space to settle within, and stay with, me and keep me coming back to it for more.

  • All We Need

    All We Need

    Critics consider the British anthology crime drama series Time, which was created by Jimmy McGovern, to be must-watch television, and they’re more right than they might realize.

    Each of these three seasons features a different set of inmates and staff within His Majesty’s Prison Service. A staff member (Stephen Joseph Graham) in season one to cite several examples starts smuggling contraband into prison to protect his son who is imprisoned elsewhere, a mother (Jodie Whittaker) sentenced for hacking an electricity box in season two to care for her children, and different young male inmates attack each other while a staff member (David Tennant) tries to maintain his standards even as his marriage is disintegrating in the third season.

    All three include a prison chaplain and Catholic nun (Siobhan Finneran), who plays a bigger part in the second and third season. She reveals when confronted in the second that she is having an affair and admits in the third that she is enduring a crisis of faith that culminates with a decision to leave the church and yet continue her social work elsewhere.

    This range as might be expected includes some plots that are stronger than others, but the acting and the writing make this show a series of compelling character sketches. These allow viewers into the characters’ lives and ask us to see from their perspectives, and to consider moral questions that could appear in different ways in our everyday lives.

    These characters’ often inspiring answers revolve around the search for dignity despite circumstances. An inmate (Tamara Lawrence) who has been sentenced to life for killing her child for example confronts other prisoners and her own shame, and in so doing seeks and finds meaning in spite of her physical constraints.

    She and the others in their choices find ways to live with dignity. In doing so, they repeatedly reaffirm the capacity to choose, and the ways such choices can make life meaningful, regardless of circumstances.

    This insight is contextualized across all three seasons by the impact of community, and the ways that communities can complement and complicate these choices. None of these characters’ choices, or our own, can be made in isolation in other words, and must also respond to others’ choices and our individual circumstances.

    The effect is an affirmation to viewers that those who confront fewer challenges and have more resources can only hope to do as well and to make meaning from our everyday experiences. They and we only have and need time, and the inclination, to do so.

  • Forging Foreign Relations

    Forging Foreign Relations

    The new movie Fjord, which won the 2026 Cannes Palme d’Or and has been praised by credible critics, asks engaging questions but is ultimately unsatisfying.

    This legal thriller written, directed, and co-produced by Cristian Mungiu tells the story of a Romanian engineer named Mihai Gheorghiu, his Norwegian wife, and nursing home caregiver, Lisbet, and their five children. Mihai and Lisbet, who are devote Christians, have relocated from Romania after Mihai’s parents died to Norway to be closer to Lisbet’s family.

    Mihai and Lisbet are suspected of child abuse by one of their kids’ teachers who also works for Child Welfare Services. Mihai denies the abuse allegations, but Lisbet and he admit to physical punishment, which triggers the removal of their children until the investigation can be completed.

    The attorney recommended by local church leaders soon refuses to represent them because she thinks Mihai is too difficult. Lisbet then asks their neighbor Mia, who is a non-practicing lawyer, married to the local school headmaster Mats, and caring for Mats’ ailing father, to represent them.

    Mihai suspects religious persecution, and Mia manages to resolve the Child Services investigation, and return the children to the Gheorghius. Mia however declines to represent them in the upcoming criminal trial, and encourages them to leave the country, which they do before it begins.

    This movie is artistically accomplished as its awards suggest. Perhaps the strongest element is the ensemble, which includes consistently strong performances that expands the focus and highlights the themes.

    The obvious context is parenting and religion, which are two sacred spaces where intervention at best is complicated. Norwegian society maintains that state obligations to children supersede parental prerogatives, and that the community is greater than the individual, which challenge the Romanian culture in which Mihai was raised and the religious beliefs Lisbet and he share.

    As a result, the movie questions the limits of tolerance in an increasingly globalized world. The Norwegian answer is that the state should err on the side of the child, and should protect them even if doing so fractures families, which even confounds Lisbet who presumably has been exposed to such principles and values.

    This tension is powerfully dramatized throughout the movie. For example, the anger-management class scene with Mihai and others was excruciating — sound strategies, unsettling conformity — while the parenting classes, which Lisbet completes off-screen, cannot mask the forced attendance of a mother who has been raising five children of various ages.

    Mihai and Lisbet resist the proposed civil settlement — the process seemed strangely less adversarial given the stakes — and got more of what they wanted. This outcome however cannot dispel the ominous shadow from the looming criminal case.

    The plot, which seemed sufficient but little more, sometimes sagged beneath the weight of these themes. Moreover, its conclusion confusingly muted the overall experience.

    What are we to do when Mia’s stepdaughter Noor, who befriended the older Gheorghiu children wades into the sea in pursuit of the ferry on which her friends and their family have escaped to Denmark? And what is the significance of Noora’s walking on water?

    Such fits and starts, which recurred throughout the movie, were frustrating, and prevented me from engaging with it as a legal thriller or even a family drama. More synthesis throughout this story that is loosely based upon actual events would have made this movie seem less unfinished, and unsatisfying.